![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Okay, lets start with some ground rules.
Fuck no flaming. If there’s a fic or a writer that really drives you insane, go ahead and say so… I’m starting this convo. by talking in generalities about good!fic vs. Bad!fic, but there’s no point in continuing if we’re gonna nice each other to death.
Also, I’m an equal opportunity mocker. I don’t get defensive about my fics. If you want to say “you suck” meh, I’ll ignore you. If you want to say… “I like your ideas but the grammar is atrocious I’ll say![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
jane2005 we’ve covered this. If you want to tell me that you think I got Brian and or Justin wrong, or I’m lazy with descriptions… tell me… it seems right to ME, but then I think the stuff all seems right to the authors. I’m good about taking constructive criticism.
Okay, so those are the rules, name names, blast bad fics, worship and rec good fics and don’t feel that because I started the post you need to leave me out either category.
Now… my ideas on what makes good fic good and bad fic bad.
Um, be warned, this got long
( ”my )
Fuck no flaming. If there’s a fic or a writer that really drives you insane, go ahead and say so… I’m starting this convo. by talking in generalities about good!fic vs. Bad!fic, but there’s no point in continuing if we’re gonna nice each other to death.
Also, I’m an equal opportunity mocker. I don’t get defensive about my fics. If you want to say “you suck” meh, I’ll ignore you. If you want to say… “I like your ideas but the grammar is atrocious I’ll say
jane2005 we’ve covered this. If you want to tell me that you think I got Brian and or Justin wrong, or I’m lazy with descriptions… tell me… it seems right to ME, but then I think the stuff all seems right to the authors. I’m good about taking constructive criticism.Okay, so those are the rules, name names, blast bad fics, worship and rec good fics and don’t feel that because I started the post you need to leave me out either category.
Now… my ideas on what makes good fic good and bad fic bad.
Um, be warned, this got long
( ”my )
